Dear New Authors, “Marketers” Won’t Reach Out Via Messages Or Comments

If you’ve posted about your book on Instagram for more than five minutes, you’ve probably seen them. “Amazing post! Send this to @TotallyRealMarketingAccount!” “Promote it on @DefinitelyNotBots!” “This deserves more readers! DM @BookGrowthExperts!” “This deserves more readers! DM @BookGrowthExperts!” Congratulations, bestie. You haven’t been discovered by a secret marketing agency. You’ve been discovered by a bot farm.

And if you’re a new author, I really, really don’t want you wasting your money on these people. Before we get into it, yes, I’m an author. I’m also a corporate content marketer who’s spent more than a decade helping brands grow online. Which is exactly why these scams are so frustrating to watch. And I’m not saying that to sell to you. I’m trying to help you avoid being scammed, because comments like the ones above aren’t the only way fake bots will try to convince you that they know marketing strategy. Let’s talk about what these bot accounts actually are, how you can spot and block them, and how you can do marketing yourself or hire a marketing expert who’s actually able to help you generate results (though that will be expensive). Ready to learn about indie author marketing? Let’s talk.

The best marketers don’t need fake engagement

As an actual marketer with a marketing day job doing real marketing things, there’s one thing that always makes me laugh: people claiming to be social media marketing experts are relying on fake social media engagement to find or convince clients.

Think about that for a second.

If your entire business is helping people grow authentic audiences or put their book in front of authentic audience, why is your own audience made up of bots? Good marketing is, ironically, one of the easiest professions to verify. You can usually tell within thirty seconds whether someone actually knows what they’re doing. Here are a few things to look for:

  • Do they create content people genuinely engage with?
  • Do they have conversations in their comments?
  • Do people share their work because it’s valuable?
  • Or are there fifty comments that all say, “Amazing!” and “Wow, so nice!” under every post?

One of those is marketing.

The other is theater.

Let me show you an example of one account that I’ve seen absolutely relentlessly targeting indie authors with spammy bot comments as of late. Given that they have a bot army at their disposal, I’m going to edit out their username so I don’t inevitably attract any review-bombing. And I’m also going to edit out the names of authors in my network who follow this account because hey, we’re all here to learn about what red flags to look for. First, let’s just glance at the profile:

See any red flags? You should. At a very high level, you should already see 607K followers and a blurb that mentions promotion and encourages you to “DM to get featured” right above a link directing you to a website. That should tell you right away that their audience isn’t authentic… They didn’t build that following of like-minded without a unifying theme like “fantasy and romance books for the girlies.” There’s nothing there that would attract a general reader… That means you, dear author, are their audience. As with vanity presses who make their money by charging authors exorbitantly for a subpar product, these guys make their money by charging authors exorbitantly for “marketing” that’s actually just bot engagement.

I also personally consider the AI profile picture to be concerning (you can read about my stance on AI, but long story short, know that I’m not a fan of generative AI and generally tend to see its use as a red flag), but I see so many real-life-human readers using it that I wouldn’t immediately be like “This guy is a bot!” based on its use alone. However, real influencers tend to have a cohesive brand that usually doesn’t lean too heavily on AI-generated slop. Remember that generating a photo with AI is free… If anyone can do it, what makes a “book promoter” or “book marketer” more skilled in generating an image than you? Nothing. So if you see AI-generated content on a “promotion” or “marketing” page, just know that you should never pay to have someone else enter a prompt for you. Generative AI use is a red flag. And if that’s how they’re presenting their brand, there’s a good chance their audience is prompt-based, too.

Let me explain that one.

Many bots nowadays are powered by AI, which means they operate off a specific prompt that encourages them to behave in a specific way. If they’re programmed to comment, for example, they’ll do so with vague praise that also sounds stiff and robotic. Let’s take a look at the comments on the above account’s most recent post:

Not a single comment mentions characters, themes, or anything about the book. These could be relevant to To Kill a Mockingbird or Fifty Shades of Grey. These are what bot engagement looks like, and you’ll notice that some do, in fact, have profile pictures. If you click on their profiles, you may even see posts that look real. Bots have gotten better. I hate to say it, but they’re doing their best to be more convincing. But you’ll also notice that none of them are engaging with eachother. As of the summer of 2026, they’re still not sophisticated enough to convincingly interact with each other. That could certainly change, but this type of behavior should be seen as a red flag.

Interestingly, the post put up just one day before this one has zero comments. For an account with over 607,000 followers, that should also be seen as a red flag. With these types of scammers, anything that looks fishy probably is.

Now, this was just one type of “marketing” scam that exists. Let’s talk about private messages and the scammers who genuinely might have a real human behind their account.

Marketers Won’t Message You

If you’ve landed on this article organically, that’s because I’ve employed SEO and AEO tactics to bring you here. I’m a content marketer, which means blabbering into the void is literally how I sell products for big international multimillion-dollar brands. And I’m very good at it. Any marketer worth their dime will also utilize different digital marketing techniques to bring you to their offerings, whether it’s their social media account or their website. What they will not do is reach out to you. Like, digital marketing is hands-off. Sales is hands-on. If they’re in your inbox pitching “marketing services,” they’re acting as salespeople, not demonstrating marketing expertise. Before you spend a dollar, ask yourself why someone who claims to specialize in attracting audiences isn’t attracting clients the same way.

Now, I did mention that some of those accounts who reach out will have a real human behind them. Truly, I don’t think it’s remarkably malicious, but you will see large numbers of “book reviewers” from countries with high English-as-a-second-language-speaking populations who offer paid reviews simply because bringing in that USD or EUR provides a high purchasing power advantage in their country. They’ll charge you very low amounts to “review your book,” and as with the marketing scam and vanity press model mentioned in the previous section, you’ll see that these guys make their money by charging authors for a subpar (often AI-generated) product. And their following? Often bot-based, mixed with real authors who have previously fallen for the scam.

And when those scammers land in my inbox, I have a bad habit. This one is funny, actually, so bear with me.

Whenever a “reviewer” or “marketer” messages me, I respond by trying to sell them my (totally real and not keyword-stuffed) services.

A while back, one account slid into my DMs with the classic pitch:

So I replied, of course. Pulled out the whole sleazy used car salesman pitch and put a marketing spin on it, pretending I’d simply seen the “paid reviews” keyword and ran with it. I’ll spare you the entirety of the message, because it’s as long as theirs was, and instead I’ll show you their response.

“I like your services and strategy… I’m in no position of paying for anything :)”

Girl. You were so close to getting it. Because not only are fake reviews like this actually illegal in the United States and the EU (and certainly other countries and territories, too), but a cold pitch is uncomfy. These guys operate knowing they’re uncomfortable, but hoping they’ll find just one author desperate enough to take the bait. Because those low prices add up, especially in countries where $15 USD is equivalent to two days’ work at a male’s wages.

Yeah. It’s a depressing truth, but it doesn’t make this practice any less predatory. Remember that if they’re approaching you banking on you making an investment to grow your dream, they’re probably not actually invested in your dream. Your book isn’t the product. You and your wallet are.

Real Marketers Demonstrate Expertise

Considering courting a marketer? Good for you. Genuinely. But some food for thought… That $75-$250 USD per marketing initiative cost I dropped in my message above wasn’t pulled out of nowhere. When I used to freelance, those were essentially my going hourly rates, depending on the project scope. And yes, for the elite skills I offered and the major brand portfolio I have, big brands were willing to match those prices. Good marketing is expensive, and even as an indie author who sells several hundred books a year and actually makes a bit of profit, I wouldn’t be able to afford a marketer at the prices I charged. And I wouldn’t be comfortable working with a marketer charging less, because again, you get what you pay for.

I recently chatted with a six-figure author who confessed that to get to $100K in net profit, she had to spend about $80K in marketing. Truthfully, I buy that. Like I said, good marketing is expensive. It’s worth it if you have the time and money to invest, but not everyone does. Because with every new marketer you bring in, they’re going to have to test and optimize to get you to where you need to be. It might feel like you’re throwing money away and not seeing immediate results, because yes, marketing is most often a customer-nurturing, long-term play. If you are ready to invest in a good marketer, you should always ask yourself:

  • If they’re selling marketing, how are they marketing? Did I discover this through research and recommendations, or did they pop up in my inbox?
  • Where are their case studies?
  • Where’s the breakdown of campaign results?
  • Where are the educational posts and blogs that are SEO-rich and well-optimized? Do they have enough influence and expertise to do thought leadership?
  • Where’s the proof that they understand audience psychology, positioning, content strategy, SEO, analytics, and advertising?

If every post is just “We’ll make you famous,” that’s not expertise. That’s wishful thinking.

We’ll talk shortly about how to learn marketing on your own, because even as a marketer, I’ll be the first to say you can DIY this shit. Truly and sincerely. It just takes a bit of investment in terms of learning how to interpret and repeat results.

But before we get too far, let’s talk about how to get rid of some of those pesky “marketers” who love to leave comments on your posts.

Protect your Instagram comments

Instagram gives you tools to deal with a lot of nonsense “marketing” slop automatically. (I’m sure other platforms do, too, but as a millennial… We’re going to walk through Instagram for this example.) Here’s how I recommend setting things up:

  1. Open Settings and activity.
  2. Tap Hidden Words.
  3. Add custom words and phrases that frequently appear in these spam comments.

You can see a few of the phrases I’ve opted for in the screenshot above. The best part? As the bots evolve, you can always add new phrases. Will every spam comment disappear? No. But you’ll dramatically cut down on the noise, and your actual readers won’t have to scroll through fake marketing pitches before they find real conversations.

The Marketing Advice I Wish Every New Author Heard

Building an audience is frustrating. I get it. Publishing a book is hard enough without wondering why the algorithm seems determined to show your work to everyone except readers.

That’s exactly why these scams work. They prey on people who desperately want someone to notice their book.

The thing is, real marketing rarely looks like magic. It starts with thoughtful positioning. Over time, you’ll come to understand your audience. You’ll see when people actually engage with your content.

As you get better at understanding what sticks, it takes consistency, experimentation, and a bit of data analysis to start learning how your brand can grow. It’s slow and intentional.

And yes, sometimes it’s frustratingly slow. Like, really slow. The reason I’ve grown so quickly as a marketer is because when I was young, I explicitly aimed to work with big brands, which meant I had big budgets to work with. Big budgets cut that timeline down because they’ll inevitably serve you more data. When you’re doing everything organically (that is, without putting money behind it), it genuinely does lead to a longer timeline. It takes a long time to experiment and learn, and that’s okay.

I’d rather see my new-to-publishing friends take their time and see what works for free than investing $20 a week on ads that go nowhere because data collection is so slow that optimization is slow.

Seriously. Take your time when you start out. A/B test. Be authentic when building your brand, and when you see genuine engagement, take the time to analyze what worked. If you posted a video of yourself talking about the tropes in your book, for example, and saw fantastic engagement, try posting a video with the same exact format that talks about something like themes instead. If it doesn’t perform as well, you know that your particular audience might have an appetite for tropes. You might make more videos about tropes then to see if you can respark that same high engagement. That’s what testing and optimization is… It’s a very slow and intentional way of analyzing what landed and seeing if you can mimic that success. In theory, it’ll get you closer to something like a formula that you can repeat time and time again.

Here’s the stinky truth, though: no formula sticks forever. Testing and optimization never end, but once you’ve got a decent grasp of what people like, you’re likely ready to start putting money behind your marketing.

Like I said earlier — you can learn to do this shit for free. Yes, for realsies. A bunch of my marketing certifications on my resume are free courses I took online just to beef up my arsenal of tools. Many of them repeated things that I already knew as a marketer, which made them kind of useless for me but also make them genuinely great resources to newbies looking to learn about marketing. Here are some courses you might consider taking:

  1. HubSpot Academy: HubSpot is my CRM and email marketing tool as an author, and I’ve worked for many clients who actually use HubSpot as their marketing engine. If you’re a newbie to marketing, truly, I recommend you start here. You can learn about email marketing, content marketing, digital marketing… You name it, they’ve got a course for it. And they’re free, so they’re an incredible resource for learning to market and advertise.
  2. Google Career Certificates: Years ago, I took the free Google Digital Garage course and found it valuable. That’s great for beginners, but the Career Certificates can take your skills even further. They’re only free for seven days before they charge a subscription fee, though, so… buckle up and dive in if you’re looking to take advantage of a free course offering. I’ll advise, however, not to get caught up in their “$71,000+ median U.S. salary for Digital Marketing” messaging. Courses like this will not get you a job in marketing… What they will do, though, is teach you the fundamentals so you can apply them to your own campaigns. And understanding the fundamentals is really where it starts.
  3. Reedsy Courses: The full disclaimer is that I haven’t tried these yet, but I know authors who have and have enjoyed them. What’s fun about free specialized courses through platforms like Reedsy is that you can really dig into your specific niche, which places like HubSpot and Google are going to keep it high-level.

Of course, watching YouTube videos by marketing experts and reading books written by marketers are also an incredible way to get hands-on. I will add that once you understand the fundamentals of marketing, it’s all about getting your hands dirty. Building ads in Google, Amazon, or Meta isn’t hard if you understand the basics of what goes into an ad, and targeting and optimization is a lot less scary when you understand that it’s an ongoing learning process. But I promise you that any marketer you can hire had to go through the same process of getting their hands dirty when they were learning to market, so it’s okay to be afraid as you’re starting out. With some focus and dedication to ongoing learning, you’ll be an expert in no time.

Long Story Short

If someone promises overnight visibility while their own page looks like a graveyard full of “Amazing post!” comments from suspiciously empty accounts, save your money. If someone is messaging you a pitch for marketing or review services, don’t engage — marketers don’t do the virtual version of door-to-door sales. And “send your post to @scammybookmarketer” comments? Block them via Hidden Words and don’t even give them any energy.

You can learn marketing on your own. Truly. It does take time, but the good news is that everything you’ll learn upfront can be done for free and it can be done better than any of those scammy services I just mentioned. So congrats on publishing your book… I can’t wait to see the way you market it.

Published by Nikki

I'm literally just a writer, guys.

Leave a Reply