The Uncomfortable Art of Getting Better at Writing

crumpled papers on the table

If you’re new here, hi, I’m Nikki. I write for a living, working in content marketing and corp comms with a background in journalism. I’ve been doing those things since 2007. Writing fiction is something I’ve always done, too, but publishing it is a new outlet for me — I started in early 2024. Why did my professional career take off while my fiction career sat on the back burner, you ask? It’s simple, really. I knew that writing fiction is easy, but writing good fiction is a long road of investing in your craft. I wanted to dive into publishing when I was fully settled into my career, when I had the time to write and rip apart manuscripts over and over again.

That’s what this article is about: the long, long road of getting better at writing.

So let’s just rip the Band-Aid off before we dive in… I started writing my upcoming gothic dark fantasy novel, Putrescence in Her Peripherals, in 2010. It will be published in late 2026.

Sixteen years is a ridiculous amount of time to spend on a single book, isn’t it? Especially when you consider that I’ve written and published other novels in the meantime. But this particular story was different. I knew there was something special about it. I loved the characters, the mythology, the atmosphere, and the larger narrative I wanted to build. I also knew that telling this story properly would require a level of finesse I hadn’t quite developed yet. And that’s what makes this particular journey special, actually. I recognized that I wasn’t quite there yet.

So I kept working on Putrescence. Slowly. Sometimes that meant putting it aside for years, sometimes returning to it with fresh eyes, and sometimes realizing that the writer who had first imagined the story wasn’t quite equipped to tell it the way it deserved to be told.

I don’t regret that decision. In fact, I think it’s one of the better decisions I’ve made as an author.

Because there’s something I’ve come to believe rather strongly: not every book you write needs to be published, and not every book you’re excited to publish is ready for readers.

That’s not an especially comfortable thing to hear when you’re starting out. Believe me, I understand. You’ve spent months, perhaps years, building a world, developing characters, and pouring your imagination onto the page. You want people to read it. You want to hold the finished book in your hands. You want to call yourself a published author.

But if you want to become a better writer, you have to be willing to prioritize the craft over the immediate gratification of publication.

And sometimes, that means getting uncomfortable.

Your First Book Should Probably Be a Practice Book

One of the best pieces of advice I can give an aspiring novelist is to consider your first book a learning experience rather than your debut. This really sucks, I know, but… Hear me out.

I don’t mean that your first manuscript is destined to be terrible. Some writers produce remarkably accomplished work early in their careers. Others write several manuscripts before finding their footing. (I think I had five or six unpublished manuscripts that I completed before I wrote what became my debut, Industrialized, so I’m very much in the latter camp.) There’s no universal timeline, and there’s certainly no shame in publishing a first novel if it’s genuinely ready.

But I do think there’s tremendous value in writing a book without the expectation that it will ever see publication. Why? Because writing a novel teaches you things that reading about writing simply cannot.

You learn how difficult it is to maintain a compelling narrative across 80,000 or 100,000 words. You discover that a fascinating premise doesn’t necessarily translate into an engaging story. You realize that characters who seem wonderfully complex in your imagination can become rather flat when you actually put them on the page.

You learn about pacing, dialogue, exposition, scene construction, characterization, and the sometimes miserable business of revision.

Most importantly, you begin to recognize your own habits. And you might not even recognize them until you’ve finished the book, left it sitting on the shelf for several months, and then returned as a reader with fresh eyes.

Maybe you over-describe everything. Maybe your dialogue sounds unnatural. Perhaps you have a tendency to explain a character’s emotions three different ways because you don’t trust the reader to understand the first one. Maybe you introduce fascinating subplots that ultimately distract from the story you’re supposed to be telling.

These are things you might not recognize when you’re writing your first few chapters. They become much more apparent when you finish a manuscript, put it away, and return to it with a critical eye. Perhaps it will take peer critiques to highlight those things, but the point is that a practice book gives you room to make mistakes without feeling that every mistake is jeopardizing your future as an author. You can experiment, rewrite entire chapters, abandon characters, change the ending, and learn what works. Anne R. Allen, author of books like No Place Like Home, points out in her blog how very silly the thought of Harper Lee publishing Go Set a Watchman first would have been. To Kill a Mockingbird was, essentially, a rewrite of that storyline, and it’s profoundly impactful, and something she likely would not have settled on without the help of her editor.

Sometimes, it takes a village. And sometimes, that village may just help you discover that the story you originally intended to write isn’t the story you actually want to tell.

That’s perfectly fine.

Your first book doesn’t have to be your first published book. Sometimes, the most valuable thing you can do with a manuscript is learn from it and move on. You can still cherish it… I certainly cherish my unpublished stories, and I love revisiting them from time to time because they’re so earnest. But the voice with which they were written is not my professional voice, and that’s exactly the role they were meant to play in my journey.

Because if they’re meant to be a story that’s shared with the world one day, you can always circle back and rewrite them once your skills are sharpened.

a person s hand on black typewriter
Photo by Maria Tyutina on Pexels.com

Learn To Separate Loving Your Story From Evaluating Your Writing

This is probably one of the hardest lessons for new writers. Hell, even as an established writer, I find that this is hard advice to give. But it’s really, really valuable.

You can love your characters and still have underdeveloped characterization. You can adore your worldbuilding and still have too much exposition. You can be incredibly excited about a romantic relationship and still fail to establish believable chemistry between the characters. What I mean by all of this is that the story you imagine and the story your readers experience are not necessarily the same thing.

When you know everything about your characters, it’s easy to assume the reader understands them, too. You know their childhoods, motivations, insecurities, relationships, and private thoughts. (Or, at least, you should. I’ve spoken before about how character analyses and webs are highly effective tools for getting to know your characters and ensuring they have real friction. That second point is so important in telling a hooky story.)

But the reader only knows what you’ve actually communicated on the page. And when you’re emotionally attached to the project, it can be very easy to be precious with your work. I always say to kill your darlings, darlin’. By that, I mean it’s important to become comfortable with critique, and you should be your own first taste of criticism by poking holes in your own story.

In terms of poking holes in characterization, consider the difference between telling someone that two characters have incredible chemistry and writing a scene in which their interactions make the reader believe it. Those are two very different accomplishments. Likewise, describing a character as intelligent doesn’t necessarily make them appear intelligent. Explaining that a protagonist is heartbroken doesn’t automatically make the reader feel their heartbreak. You have to earn those reactions. And that’s why letting your novel rest is so beneficial… Reddit users recommend leaving it be a month or two after you complete it to ensure you return with fresh eyes.

And once you do return to it, poking holes doesn’t mean you should eliminate descriptive prose, internal monologue, or emotional exposition. Different genres and styles have different conventions, and sometimes repetition is a deliberate stylistic choice, for example. Writers Helping Writers has a great blog post that outlines a few ways to poke holes in your story, but one of my tools is a reverse read… By that, I mean reading your plot outline backwards to ensure you can cleanly spot cause-and-effect. I’m a huge proponent of Chekhov’s gun, and your first novel is a great testing ground for this concept. Have you added any features in the story, like a gun in Act I, that doesn’t go off by Act III? Then you need to cut it or ensure it has actual significance in your story.

And while you’re poking through your draft, remember that if you want a reader to feel something, ask yourself whether the scene actually creates that feeling or whether you’re simply telling them what they’re supposed to feel.

It’s a surprisingly useful distinction.

Learn To Accept Criticism (Even When It Hurts)

You’ve been waiting so patiently, so let’s talk about the uncomfortable one: criticism.

One of my favorite stories to tell is about how the second book in the Industrialized series was initially received. For context, the original draft included the discovery of the fact that book one’s MMC had died. Anyway… My sister got about 100 pages or so in and candidly told me, “I liked the first book, but this one isn’t good. Sorry. You need to rewrite it.” At the time, I was offended, but… She was right. I went to my partner and shared the beginning of the story with him, and then I tapped in another alpha reader, and all agreed overwhelmingly that the story lost something special without the MMC. All in all, the book needed a rewrite. And I had to revisit my outline and figure out a way to make the MMC not dead, though the ending of Part One: Experiment had very much implied that he was at least lost in action.

That was some harsh criticism to swallow. But it was really worth it in the end. Sitting with the outline and reflecting on what my readers had told me they needed was truly invaluable in getting that series to the finish line. And my sister was the perfect critique partner, because we’re sisters. We bicker. She wasn’t afraid of hurting my feelings.

If you intend to publish your writing, you’re going to receive criticism at some point. Some of it will be wonderful and constructive. Some of it will be poorly communicated. Some of it will be completely subjective. And occasionally, someone will identify a problem in your manuscript that you desperately wish they hadn’t noticed.

That’s part of the process.

Truly, I understand how personal writing can feel. You’ve created something from nothing, and criticism of that creation can feel like criticism of you. It’s especially difficult when someone dislikes a character you’ve grown attached to or identifies a problem in a scene you’ve rewritten twenty times.

But you have to learn to separate your emotional attachment to your work from your ability to evaluate it. That’s a really hard lesson to learn, so if you have someone in your life who (like my sister) is trustworthy and also not afraid to rip that Band-Aid off, it’s worth seeing if they’ll at least read a scene or two.

Because early on, it’s much easier to get feedback from someone you know and trust than a critique partner. But whenever you start to get that feedback, remember that a critique isn’t an attack on your imagination. It’s information about how your work is being received.

One of the most valuable things you can learn is how to listen to criticism without automatically accepting or rejecting it.

men having a disagreement
Photo by Monstera Production on Pexels.com

For example, imagine a beta reader tells you that your protagonist is boring. Your immediate reaction might be that the reader simply doesn’t understand the character. Perhaps they haven’t reached the chapter where the protagonist’s motivations become clear or they dislike the character’s personality or they just prefer a different kind of protagonist altogether.

All of those things are possible.

But before dismissing the feedback or typing up a snappy reply, step away from the keyboard ask yourself a more useful question: Why did this reader find my protagonist boring?

Is the character passive? Do they lack a clear objective? Are they repeatedly reacting to events rather than making decisions? Have you spent so much time explaining their personality that you’ve neglected to give them meaningful things to do? And more importantly, is this information that other early readers have echoed?

You don’t necessarily have to make the protagonist more likable. You don’t even have to agree with the reader’s proposed solution. But you should investigate the problem they’ve identified. I also want to emphasize that you should pay attention when the same criticism comes from multiple people, because that’s the greatest tell that the critique may be something you should take into serious account.

One reader might dislike your pacing because they prefer faster stories. Five readers independently telling you that the middle of your book drags is a different matter. On the same token, one person might dislike your descriptive style, but several readers telling you they struggle to understand what’s happening in your scenes should make you reconsider your approach.

Repeated feedback is a pattern, and patterns deserve attention. When information is provided to you, be willing to consider that your readers might be identifying something you haven’t noticed.

And whatever you do, don’t punish beta readers for being honest. If you ask someone to evaluate your manuscript, you’re asking them to give you their reading experience, not to reassure you that you’re talented. The average beta reader isn’t there to stroke your ego.

But, of course, that does exist. One author I know recently talked about essentially hiring a cheerleader who would read snippets and comment on what they like just to keep them motivated. And that’s totally okay! If you only want encouragement, ask for encouragement. There’s nothing wrong with needing that occasionally. Just don’t confuse it with editorial feedback and you’re golden.

Understand What Kind of Editing Your Manuscript Actually Needs

Another common mistake I see among newer authors is misunderstanding the different types of editing. Because contrary to what early career writers may believe, editing isn’t a single service, and hiring an editor doesn’t automatically mean your manuscript is going to become publishable.

Different editorial stages address different problems:

  • Developmental editing looks at the big picture, taking into account plot structure, pacing, characterization, narrative logic, scene construction, and whether the story is accomplishing what it sets out to accomplish.
  • Line editing focuses on the writing itself… sentence structure, prose, clarity, rhythm, flow, and stylistic consistency.
  • Copy editing addresses grammar, punctuation, usage, and consistency.
  • Proofreading catches remaining errors in the final formatted manuscript. I always say that if your book has been touched, it needs a proofread. Every. Single. Time. Personally, I have an app on my phone that reads my manuscripts to me as I’m driving, and it’s been an incredible time saver for this part of the process.

These services have different purposes, and the order matters. Lemme explain why.

Imagine spending a considerable amount of money having every sentence in your manuscript polished, only to discover afterward that your central relationship doesn’t work, your protagonist lacks a convincing motivation, or your second act needs to be substantially rewritten. You’ve now paid to polish material that may need to be discarded… And that hurts.

person reading document
Photo by Ron Lach on Pexels.com

A line editor cannot fix an underdeveloped plot. A copy editor cannot give your protagonist a personality. And proofreading? That can’t rescue a manuscript that hasn’t been properly revised.

If you’re receiving consistent feedback about structural problems, consider a developmental editor before investing in sentence-level editing. This is so, so important, and it’s a very convincing reason to open your manuscript to alpha and beta readers. They’re a great way to pressure test your story, but be sure to properly vet anyone you’re considering sharing your work with.

They’re a great first line of defense that’s often totally free. And after you tap in alpha and beta readers, if you can’t afford professional editing yet, don’t panic. There are books, courses, writing groups, and experienced critique partners who can help you develop your skills. Just make sure you’re seeking the right kind of help for the problems you’re experiencing.

Learn To Recognize Your Writing Habits

Every writer has habits. The trick is learning to recognize which ones are helping you and which ones are holding you back.

There are a few things I’d encourage newer writers to watch for.

The first is overexplaining.

Do you describe a character’s emotional reaction, follow it with a physical response, and then explain what that physical response means? Don’t do that. It makes your work feel hollow. Depth and implication come from not spoon-feeding your reader. Allowing your characters to exist in a space that’s not wholly described allows for interpretation and, therefore, visualization, which helps make your character feel alive to your reader.

Do your characters repeatedly think about things the reader already understands? This is a harder one to watch for, admittedly, because if you’re writing, you’re close to the story and often simply putting ideas on paper. In my first drafts, I often put things like this into the story just to help me remember what themes I’m working with when I go back to skim and see what ground I’ve already covered. But if you can, try to remove things that are glaringly repetitive or kinda spoon-feedy. Also, encourage your early readers to call out things that feel unnecessary or repetitive. I have one beta reader who’s so dedicated to this that she’ll call out when a word has been used more than once in the same stretch of paragraphs… It’s such an attentive note that it’s one I try to take with me when I alpha or beta reader for other authors, too.

So seriously, communicate with your team of readers.

Because sometimes a little more explanation is necessary. Sometimes it creates atmosphere or reinforces a theme. You may not know if these are being interpreted as such without a little help, and that’s totally okay.

Then, there’s passive protagonists.

Does your protagonist actually drive the story, or do things simply happen to them? Are they making decisions, pursuing objectives, and creating consequences? A character doesn’t have to be particularly competent or confident, but they should have some agency.

As a reader, nothing takes me out of a story faster than when the protagonist just floats from scene to scene, having things happen to them but not really influencing the direction those things go.

On that note, though, lemme give you an example of when this can actually work: when it’s intentional.

In my upcoming gothic dark fantasy, Putrescence, my main character is very passive. Things happen to Aodhán, and he largely goes with the flow. However, his inability to question things and take appropriate, timely action causes friction with his sister and leads to some very severe consequences. It’s that consequence detail that makes his character so realistic… And helps prevent him from this too-precious layer of mystical protection authors often give their MCs. To avoid the passive protagonist issue, let them get hurt. You don’t have to make them suffer, but don’t coddle them.

Let’s talk about dialogue that exists primarily to convey information.

If two characters already know something, why are they explaining it to each other? Exposition is necessary, especially in fantasy, but conversations should feel like conversations. Characters should have their own interests, disagreements, and reasons for speaking.

Please, please, please don’t use dialogue to move your story forward. That gets so boring, so fast.

Watch for repetitive emotional beats.

Are your characters constantly sighing, frowning, narrowing their eyes, clenching their jaws, or looking away? Physical reactions are useful, but they become monotonous when they’re the default response to every emotion.

Another thing I’m going to call out here is adverbs, or words ending in -ly. If every action is done loudly, softly, enthusiastically, anxiously, they start to feel really, really hollow. Be extremely careful not to overuse adverbs.

And keep an eye out for beautiful scenes that don’t accomplish anything.

This one can be particularly difficult for writers who enjoy descriptive prose. You might have written a gorgeous passage describing a castle, a forest, or a character’s internal reflections. But what does the scene actually contribute? Does something change? Does the reader learn something meaningful? Does it develop a relationship, advance the plot, or establish something that becomes important later?

Not every scene needs a dramatic revelation. Quiet scenes have value, too. But they should still have a purpose. There’s a meme about how gothic and fantasy writers will spend three pages describing a tree… It’s an internet joke for a reason. Don’t be the butt of that joke.

Also, be careful not to confuse complexity with depth.

A complicated magic system, an elaborate political hierarchy, and a thousand years of fictional history don’t automatically make a story sophisticated. Complexity is only valuable when it contributes to the reading experience. It goes without saying that too much complexity can be detrimental to readers.

Remember that your goal as a writer is to give readers enough information to understand and appreciate the story they’re reading.

And one more thing I want to call out: don’t confuse word count with quality. Writing 100,000 words is an accomplishment, but it doesn’t mean those 100,000 words are all necessary. One year for NaNoWriMo (which I’ve always participated in independently, not as part of any organization), I wrote 120k words in a month. It was an incredible feat, but the resulting story was one I openly admit was bad.

Long story short, sometimes becoming a better writer means learning what to remove.

Read Critically, Not Just Recreationally

One of the best ways to improve your writing is to read. A lot. This is advice I give to marketers, and it’s even more true for authors.

But I’d also encourage you to occasionally put on your editorial hat while you’re doing it.

When you encounter a character you love, ask yourself why they work. Is it their dialogue? Their decisions? Their relationships? How the author introduces them? Alternatively, when a character makes you feel absolutely nothing, why is that? What makes them feel uninspired?

When a scene makes you emotional, take the time to examine how the author achieved that response. Did they establish the relationship beforehand? Did they use a particular detail or image? Was the emotional impact created through dialogue, action, internal reflection, or some combination?

When you find yourself bored, ask why.

You don’t have to turn every reading experience into a homework assignment. That’ll ruin the fun of reading so damn fast. But learning to recognize effective storytelling in other people’s work can help you identify what your own writing is missing.

And read outside your preferred genre. If you write fantasy, try literary fiction. If you write romance, try a mystery. If you write horror, try historical fiction. When all is said and done, make sure you’re super familiar with your own genre, though. It is important to recognize what readers of that genre are likely expecting in any given work.

woman reading a book beside the window
Photo by Rahul Shah on Pexels.com

Stop Treating Publication as the Finish Line

There’s a peculiar pressure in writing communities to publish quickly. But obviously, I’ve been building toward this point for the entire article — publication is not the finish line. Finishing the book is. And then the next finish line is ripping it up. Then doing it again. Then welcoming readers. Then maybe publishing it.

But it’s totally fine to just, like, not do that.

We so often celebrate debut announcements, release schedules, preorder campaigns, and authors who manage to produce several books a year. And those things are exciting, but publication isn’t proof that you’ve mastered the craft. I’ve read many published books that don’t meet my expectations for quality. With indie publishing so widely accessible, absolutely anyone can publish.

But making that decision before your work is ready to be published can actually hurt your career, assuming you’re interested in longevity.

So if you’re still receiving consistent feedback about major problems in your writing, your next step shouldn’t be a book launch. It should be a writing course, a substantial revision, a critique group, or a few months spent studying the areas where you’re struggling. Whatever you decide, there’s no shame in it.

Again, you don’t have to publish every manuscript you finish. You don’t have to prove your worth as a writer by producing books as quickly as possible.

You can take your time.

You can write something that never gets published.

You can abandon a manuscript and start again.

You can return to an old story years later and discover that you’re finally capable of telling it properly.

Like I mentioned before, that’s exactly what happened with my upcoming book.

Give Your Stories the Time They Deserve

When I first started writing my gothic dark fantasy in 2010, I couldn’t have imagined that I’d still be working on it sixteen years later. I certainly didn’t plan to spend that long developing it.

But I knew what I wanted the story to become, and I wasn’t satisfied with the versions I was producing. As I developed as a writer, I became increasingly aware of what the manuscript needed. Sometimes that meant rewriting, and often, it meant stepping away.

The story didn’t become less important because I delayed publishing it. If anything, my investment in it made me more determined to get it right.

And that’s ultimately what I want newer writers to take away from this.

You don’t owe the world a published book simply because you’ve written one. You owe yourself the opportunity to become the writer you want to be.

Take criticism seriously. Learn to revise. Read widely. Study your weaknesses rather than avoiding them. Find people who will be honest with you, and develop the confidence to distinguish useful feedback from personal preference.

Most importantly, don’t let your enthusiasm for a story convince you that the manuscript is already as good as it can be.

Passion gives you a reason to write. Practice gives you the tools to improve. Humility gives you the opportunity to learn.

You need all three.

And sometimes, the best thing you can do for a story you love is give yourself a little more time to become the person capable of telling it.

Published by Nikki

I'm literally just a writer, guys.

Leave a Reply